Sister Stories: Bait & Switch

When Ivy Wolfe overhears Carter Cruise chatting on the phone, she figures out that her stepsister has a thing for girls. Feeling mischievous, Ivy hatches a plan: she writes a steamy letter, fakes the signature of Carter's girlfriend, and hands it over with a sly grin. The note tells Carter to be ready at midnight, back door unlocked, lights off. When the clock strikes twelve, Ivy slips into the room and whispers so Carter won't catch on. Carter, following every instruction to the letter, has no clue her stepsister is the one creeping up behind her. Ivy runs her hands over Carter's breasts, and when Carter tries to speak, Ivy hushes her and tells her to cover her eyes. Carter obeys while Ivy kisses and sucks on her neck. Ivy lays her down and starts teasing her pussy with eager fingers, then climbs on top and grinds against her until Carter is nearly screaming with pleasure. But when Carter finally peeks, the jig is up: it's not her girlfriend at all, it's Ivy. She shoves Ivy off, demanding to know what the hell is going on. Ivy just shrugs, reminding her they're only stepsisters, so where's the harm? Before Carter can protest, Ivy tosses her back onto the couch and kisses her deeply. Carter frets about their parents finding out, but Ivy promises this will stay their sweet little secret. Bait, switch, and a whole lot of tribbing later, these two blondes prove that curiosity always gets the cat.